Tuesday 14 March 2017

A Yogi was Very Sure of "Science"


New blog on the kid : A Yogi was Very Sure of "Science" · Assorted retorts from yahoo boards and elsewhere : Two Quorans answering "What is the best answer to someone who says the universe is only 6,000 years old?" (quora, obviously) · New blog on the kid : An Unpleasant Debate with a Scandinavian · Assorted retorts from yahoo boards and elsewhere : Other Answers, Where I do Arguing on Matters Not Persons, Crossing words with Iñaki Rodriguez under Two Answers

Q
What is the best answer to someone who says the universe is only 6,000 years old?
https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-best-answer-to-someone-who-says-the-universe-is-only-6-000-years-old


Jacqueline van der Voort
Therapist, Mother, Freeish Thinker, yoga teacher, meditator
Written Sun
Erm, well, I don't see the question they're asking? If someone says that the universe is 6000 years old, then I am not going to waste my and their time by starting to argue their conviction. Choose your battles, and this one you're not going to win unless it really _is_ posed as a question, i.e. coming from someone who genuinely wants to know more. Then you can pull some science out of the bag. If it's a conviction, just give it up; they likely have a lot invested in their 6000 year old universe, I mean, if this person has the capacity to ignore _science_ in order to protect their investment, then they have the capacity to ignore every single word you say, in fact, ignoring you is their greatest talent.

"comments"
The author has disabled comments for this answer.

Mine on that one:
so the yoga teacher has so chosen to ignore evidence from YECs that she will not even take comments ...

Other
my own on same one plus some possible debate where I commented under other answers is upcoming, I hope.


I tried to notify her by sending her a link here in a PM, but she was not taking PM's either, at least I found no button for doing so. She is however a hypnotherapist from Haag university (Haagse Hoogschool) and lives in London.

1 comment: